ackoff所说的omission和commission是什么？

heicuo(呵护) 管理员

2009-12-04 12:33:10

There is a sin of omission as well as of commission. 【諺】 既有不該做而做的事,也有該做而不做的事,這兩者都是過錯.

赞

• 

  heicuo (呵护) 管理员 楼主 2009-12-04 12:50:16

  基督教的说法：

  罪并非单单我们做了坏事，也是有好的事，我们都不肯去行。 (Sin of Commission and Sin of Omission)

  删除 |

  赞 回复
• 

  heicuo (呵护) 管理员 楼主 2009-12-04 12:51:43

  经济人的说法：

  決策後悔(Regret of Omission and Commission)：指投資人因為決策錯誤而產生的利得減少或損失之增加之現象，又可分為該做而沒有做的後悔(regret of omission)，以及做錯事的後悔(regret of commission)；由於人類的本性會特別專注於異常或特殊的事件，而這種對於特殊事件專注的傾向會加重後悔的情緒，做錯事的後悔尤其明顯，因此，做錯事的後悔比該做而沒做的後悔更為強烈。

  删除 |

  赞 回复
• 

  heicuo (呵护) 管理员 楼主 2009-12-04 13:14:51

  初步理解

  “胡作非为”VS“不作为”

  “犯之过”VS“不为之过”

  删除 |

  赞 回复
• 

  heicuo (呵护) 管理员 楼主 2009-12-04 13:21:34

  做了不该做的事情，不对；该做的事情不做，也不对。

  删除 |

  赞 回复
• 

  heicuo (呵护) 管理员 楼主 2009-12-04 21:29:40

  “不作为” 不确切

  应该用

  “当为不为”或“忽弃当为”

  删除 |

  赞 回复
• 

  王荣欣 (低端人口之后无社会学。) 2010-05-09 22:32:10

  出自阿科夫何书

  删除 |

  赞 回复
• 

  heicuo (呵护) 管理员 楼主 2010-05-12 09:40:57

  来自徐志跃老师写的《追思艾科夫》 http://www.21cbh.com/HTML/2010-1-14/162119_2.html 网上应该能搜到。我找到一篇介绍： http://www.pegasuscom.com/levpoints/ackoff_a-lifetime-of-systems-thinking.html All learning ultimately derives from mistakes. When we do something right, we already know how to do it; the most we get out of it is confirmation of our rightness. Mistakes are of two types: commission (doing what should not have been done) and omission (not doing what should have been done). Errors of omission are generally much more serious than errors of commission, but errors of commission are the only ones picked up by most accounting systems. Since mistakes are a no-no in most corporations, and the only mistakes identified and measured are ones involving doing something that should not have been done, the best strategy for managers is to do as little as possible. No wonder managerial paralysis prevails in American organizations.

  删除 |

  赞 回复
• 

  月城雪兔 (CASIC) 2015-08-21 21:29:49

  罪的定义：(从圣经观点看): 任何违背、违抗神律法或旨意的思想、行为、言语或状态。 希腊文 （hamartia） 的意思是 : “不中的”、“偏离公义的道路”。不只具体的错误行为。这包括了过犯的罪行（sin of commission） 与忽略的罪行（sin of omission）；不能行正确的事也是罪 。 commission：the action of committing a crime or offence omission：a failure to do something, especially something that one has a moral or legal obligation to do

  删除 |

  赞 回复
• 

  月城雪兔 (CASIC) 2015-08-21 22:44:41

  Things the language does that it shouldn't do------sins of commission Things it dosen't do that it should------sins of omission Things that are completely off the wall------sins of mission

  删除 |

  赞 回复
• 

  heicuo (呵护) 管理员 楼主 2015-08-22 10:20:39

  【不能行正确的事也是罪】，嗯

  删除 |

  赞 回复
• 

  heicuo (呵护) 管理员 楼主 2016-12-25 09:03:29

  What does the Bible say about sins of omission? https://www.compellingtruth.org/sin-of-omission.html

  删除 |

  赞 回复
• 

  heicuo (呵护) 管理员 楼主 2016-12-25 09:34:50

  What does the Bible say about sins of commission? https://www.compellingtruth.org/sin-of-commission.html

  删除 |

  赞 回复

你的回复